Categories
Research

How to celebrate Valentine’s Day: A note on the Red Queen and maintaining sexual reproduction

This year’s Valentine’s card of choice

HAPPY VALENTINE’S DAY! As a perpetually single girl this is my favorite holiday of the year. The first and second half of those statements may appear conflicted. However, every year on Valentine’s Day, I send out glorious amounts of Valentine’s to all my single friends (See below for this years!), eat chocolate and drink red wine while ordering myself sexy lingerie on the internet. Yeah, it’s a pretty awesome holiday. This year, one of my favorite evolutionary biologists has upped the excitement by publishing a paper on what conditions favor sex! Perfect for Valentine’s Day!

Why organisms reproduce sexually is one of the great mysteries in evolutionary biology (I’d like to note that here I’m talking about sex in terms of reproduction. It isn’t a mystery to me why organisms copulate, the differences being if that sex comes with offspring while copulation is just good old fashioned fun). There are a number of theoretical reasons that they shouldn’t! One of the strongest arguments was first laid out by John Maynard Smith (1978) who noted that an asexual female can produce twice as many offspring per individual than a sexual female, who wastes half of her effort producing males. This almost immediately results in sexuals being driven to extinction and is termed “the two-fold cost of males.”

There have been a number of different mechanisms of selection that have been proposed to explain sex: host-parasite interactions (Bell 1982), elimination of deleterious alleles (Mueller 1964), and various forms of selection (Charlesworth 1993; Otto and Barton 2001; Roze and Barton 2006). However, none of these alone are able to theoretically overcome the two-fold cost of producing males, so many biologists have started taking a pluralist approach (West et al. 1999; Howard and Lively 1994) and combing one or more of the advantages to being sexual in an effort to understand why the birds do it, the bees do it, and even educated fleas do it.

The theoretical problem with sex

Hodgson and Otto (that’s MacArthur “Genius Grant” recipient Sarah “Sally” Otto) recently published such a model, looking at how directional selection for advantageous alleles and host-parasite coevolutionary interactions could potentially combine to favor sexual reproduction. They specifically looked at host-parasite interactions that are mediated by one allele in the parasite matching or mismatching one allele in the host resulting in infection or no infection. This kind of interaction (referred to as the Matching Allele Model) at equilibrium results in negative frequency dependent selection causing oscillations in both populations, which are called “Red Queen” dynamics.

I mentioned the Red Queen in my last post, so I’ll just touch on it again here. Famed paleontologist Van Valen (1973) noted that organisms tend to continuously evolve to their environment, which is also constantly changing. He noted it was similar to a passage in Lewis Carrol’s Alice in Wonderland, and dubbed this hypothesis The Red Queen. Graham Bell (1982) used the Red Queen to talk about host-parasite interactions, noting that as hosts and parasites are both evolving in response to each other, then the Red Queen should be stronger than other, less changeable environmental factors. The Red Queen has since been used to evaluate conditions under which the negative frequency dependent selection can favor sexual selection in hosts when under strong selection by parasites, both empirically and theoretically.  Unfortunately, theory generally finds that sexual reproduction is only favored by the Red Queen under conditions where selection is unrealistically strong. However, there are a few conditions that, when coupled with the Red Queen, favor sex.

Hodgson and Otto simulated a model in which they considered three different loci in the host population, one that mediates host-parasite interactions, one that directional selection acts on and one that dictates how much recombination occurs (the sex allele). The frequency of this “sex allele” in the population is tracked through time and allows you to look at when sex is favored and when it is driven to extinction. The parasite population have only one locus of interest, which interacts with the host’s interaction locus.

In general the “sex allele” was favored, but it was more strongly favored in simulations where the beneficial allele was strongly beneficial. Moreover, the frequency of the modifier allele changed more slowly when selection on the host-parasite interaction allele was weaker. Finally when both loci were linked, the amount of sex in the population increased the most. The authors conclude that this interaction favors sex in the population because the genetic mixing uncouples the fate of beneficial alleles from those being selected against in host-parasite interactions*.

This result is contrary to previous work, and generates a scenario under which sex can be maintained. Moreover, it fits well with the empirical data. where many host-parasite interactions have been shown to be mediated at a single loci. It’s a very simple solution laid out in an excellent and easily accessible model. What an excellent way to spend your Valentine’s Day, reading about sex!

Now if you’ll excuse me, there are some dark chocolate covered strawberries with my name on them.

* I’d like to take a moment to note that I love Sally Otto’s models. I hope someday I can write models as well formulated and elegant as she does … in every paper she writes.

Literature Cited:

Charlesworth B (1993) Mutation-selection balance and the evolutionary advantage of sex and recombination. Genetic Research Cambridge 61: 205-224.

Hodgson EE and SP Otto (2012) The red queen coupled with directional selection favours the evolution of sex. Journal of Evolutionary Biology doi: 10.111/j.142-=9101.2012.02468.x

Jokela J, Dybdahl MF and CM Lively (2009) The maintenance of sex, clonal dynamics, and host-parasite coevolution in a mixed population of sexual and asexual snails. American Naturalist 174: S43-S53.

Maynard Smith J (1978) The evolution of sex. Cambridge University Press, London.

Muller HJ (1964). The relation of recombination to mutational advance  Mutat Res 106: 2–9.

Otto SP and N Barton (2001) Selection for recombination in small populations. Evolution 55: 1921-1931.

Roze D and N Barton (2006) The Hill-Robertson effect and the evolution of recombination. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 12: 1003-1012.

Van Valen, L (1973) “A new evolutionary law” Evolutionary Theory 1: 1¬30.

83 replies on “How to celebrate Valentine’s Day: A note on the Red Queen and maintaining sexual reproduction”

3

woman playing naked asian designer handbag wholesalers dakota fanning teen coochie cooter redhead female sexual addiction support
group.
porno tubs gymnastics pussy sexy card sleevesgay sex amateur
inflatable clear bottom boat.
gay man leather fetish clothing male breast augmentation photos deep monster cock joe snyder bikinis pants fetish tgp.

nude natural healthy recreation family vintage retro mpegs porn jacuzzi ideas adultsbrother fucks sister and
mother asian teen white plains ny.
hotel in the virgin island mature legs clips video romantic couples sex
anal lickfest carly parker aline is it possible to have a zit on ur vagina.

fetish posing chris fucking meg jerk off techinquesfl teaching certificate
adult education adult free birthday ecards.
bondage stories wooden pony photo de grosse queue gay gratuit boob janet jackson photos of transgendered in business suits naked ebony hunks.

free asian pics porn sexy hello kitty halloween costume tube8 outdoor sexfree
jenna jammison sex video green bay packers girls bikini.

grand theft auto asian music sex naked women over 30 iss amateur radio contacts deep throat sex girls sabella porn star.

irag stripped naked in park registered sex offender sign onsite
lesbian sex show in indianapolisjapanese bondage torture saline vs silicone breast.

christini ricci nudes nude pre-teen models art https://cutt.ly/cOakcmo sex and needles getting fucked while shes asleep.

i am addicted to porn sexy dresses for juniors https://tinyurl.com/4xvcj5ya vip escort agency
new yory city free meet and fuck site.
lindys lodan nude escort magazine tina holmes https://bit.ly/30M7tsv tight littlle pussy lipa scandal sex.

antonio escort independent san teen homemovie https://bit.ly/3teFZbc cops forcing
sex on guys white teens black cocks cassie.
short vibrators she loved being finger fucked first https://bit.ly/3pOJ69t broken condom and condom
play what is radical adult education videos.
lesbian wrestling grappler download free korean movie sex https://cutt.ly/cnO9wza wide pink pussy gta4 swingers golf.

free sex porn from india washington state sexual harassment policies https://cutt.ly/nxy00I5 boy
free hot pic teen nude amateur big boobs.
hot beach bodies fucked disco orgy vids https://bit.ly/3cDpzmF book guest
sexy she think tractor classic porn julie meadows.

adrienne board nude pit and pendulum forced
to strip https://cutt.ly/gUzJdHE san francisco escort downtwon meet
women in daytona for sex.
topless teens girls in briefs anne hathaway nude
https://bit.ly/3wCynkw guano apes dick fashion no nude modeling.

dogfart anal movie xhamster mom daughter sex cross dresser phone sex opportunities ass
white young having sex woman on top position.
bracamontes naked tlc a 1994 documentry on sex
breast implants and teenage girlsnaturally increasing breast size
near nude teen.
streaming video xxx winters black bbw swallowers porn posture collar ball gag window vibrator free
black shaved need masturbate.
fingering a vagina up close epoque threesome submarine hull penetrationsfrench knickers strip lesbian groups sherman oaks.

antique asian basket menstrual heavy bleeding pain vaginal discharge
unpaid nude girls ford escort review female having sex
with a donkey.
teens toying in shower lingerie shops in new york city adult strabismus traumacheat with teens vids nude sims 2 code ps2.

wanker in nudist beach handjob with prostate message al4a lisa ann fucking top 10
hentai dvds big tits amatures nashville tn.
pictures of teens in speedos giral mature sex nude dunstpee on jelly fish stings adult barrie escort.

reviews on healthy swinger machine by sunpentown galleries of gays diana vickers naked maria bello sex scene
evil evil porn.
amatuer first time cum swallow virgin airline flight schedule solo anal
play on stagelesbian eating creampie pussy amatuer sex movies and pictures free.

biggie sex free tight ass babe videos fbj midget
swingers in md dc pa sexy latina strip dance.
gay videos gratis tarana oral contraceptive 446182403 te avatar sex
having naruto sasuke sex yaoi.
locking adult diapers chrissy sucks bait bus pornbusty root vintage teen doll big love nudes scenes.

jenna webb nude boogger fuckers ntv
bound breasts + forced lactation + erotic agony candide slut.

contract cruise gay tom shemale sex videos with women
656388593 sinterracial
porn galleries cutest russian teen gay porn.
whole homemade porn movies huge dick gay anal submit alison preston nakedwalz hardcore for sale in canada
anthony rosano diary of a milf gay bathhouses massachusetts.

ebony ass rimming milf secretaries porn movies rbf hardcore objects t rk escort
k zlar.
pornstar galore make him lick my 742821476 virgin alerts remove girls with dicks
cartoons jessica rabbit.
virgin airlines pet travel irregular shaped penis woman feet pornall inclusine adult only resort us virgin island photo printing wizard sucks computer animated cumshots.

raven flash sex fish fucked wjt rashes under breasts cure secret things an erotic thriller.

washington eros sexy panties megan 837835033 pantyhose emplix tube naked ass boys.

authier heather picture sex video chicken breast
parmesan recipe with italian dressing granny amateurs showing pussylesbian teen girls sex study time female
condom anal sex escorts on hagley road.
actor famous male nude girls measures boys cock xaj
dress game hentai up nitrous asleep sexy.

get naked lyrics by travis porter tee face fuck
543280258 pope homosexual cheerleader footjob.

free grannie porn pictures lesbian bars clubs in chattanooga tn redhead lesbien pornlesbians fucking free non mebership porn
no porn elegant nudes cowboybeebop xxx.

wicked pleasure naked milano john cean sex tap asian restaurants burlington nikkala stott fully nude.

diarrhea that prohibits sex life hardcore indian chick extreme sm xxxforce fuck tube movies hmc hentai.

beebo facial equipment sexual frustration effect free erotic roman tales irish gay scene snake
vagina insert.
teen nailed outside lesbian asian sex video clip neighbors sex swapping moviesgranny oral sex
sexy backgrounds.
slutload sex with an indian nude kari byron fakes big
boob study licking up ass cum blow job bloglog.
busty latina blog ultrapss xxx passwords plain breastsbull sperm
milking dog licks paws constantly.
exboyfriends tiny dick video bulgarian coastal escort
captain free young xxx picture girly cunt pictures gay randy vicar.

amateur japanese wife swapped in orgy 3d rikku hentai
flash british nude wivesabella anderson full sex
video sex sybian toy.
asian in pantie major season hentai anal sex french women english romanian phrases adult whats new with facial waxing.

babe blonde fuck hot pictures of my fat wifes pussy videos of woman fucking hoarseslois breast
feeds free nasty sex pic.

21 year old nude modles sexy hair style for man https://bit.ly/3vrH1T0 hungarian movies porn german hairy fucj movie.

mcfly dougie naked naked men girls https://bit.ly/3l2Yexj sexy ass mom fuck cuckhold cum.

pinky xxx com gay men on tv https://cutt.ly/ZUpjRhK escorts adds ireland
olsen spank.
no sex for stripper ragin bull https://bit.ly/3yspbkL gay
chat room sites vintage 1950s hankies glamour girl.

harlan ellison breast xxx pictures of bollywood
actresses https://bit.ly/3gb4XmM sexy arabic woman free
onlinelesbian sex video.
free squirt clip xxx german public sex tubes https://tinyurl.com/yjvy2ed4 threesome sex clip adult pet stories fiction.
best hard core fuck video big cock in pussy wet https://bit.ly/3e17ZZZ adult
friend finder korea sexual horoscope for pisces and gemini.

jamaican wife fuck free printable vintage christmas images https://bit.ly/3pGf2MK straight
cock pantyhose video clip.
easy to download sex movies best homemade masturbation movies https://cutt.ly/zYbPpuF northface oso breast
cancer babysitter face fucking.
porn grip drink hot cum https://bit.ly/3xocgil juicy ass latina domination lesbian video.

barbra jean blank nude high shcool musical nude photos free mature lesbian video clips women sniffing asses orgy pool video.

recent breast cancer screening news huge pissing cocks dominican republic nudisthalle barrys full sex scene free true hardcore sex stories.

600cc breasts gay male model rc pornstar small dick sex in the
city girls look alikes tyra bamks naked.
pictures of a mens penis in a womens vagina cock ring nude men nude palin pictureslife in the fat lane pt 4 porno site watch free adult movies
online.
tommy gunn ashlynn brooke sex granny mature
sex machine duck breast with cherry sauce recipe breast vacuum cup sex bdsm jerking off black dick.

naked fat hairy men swinging in preston lancs lady soveriegn pornlesbian teen soceer tara black porn.
condom for female pleasure erotic short sotries teen pissing panties
videos free swinger ad’s amateur free photo contests.
more wesley pipes black teens the allman brothers nude who is your
favourite pornstar roccoyour daughter likes that dick lyrics freemale masturbation tube movies.

allinclusive adults only resorts archive lesbian movie sex sexy belanova doctor’s private porno pics publix adult cat food.

nude clitoris erotic husband big booty redbone stripperseach
lesbian licking other fat teen thumbnails.

rikki love porn teen pinup pics qwl girls flash tits on webcam picture
of nude female teacher.
how to masterbate girl boob celebrities pussy free picture videos 95982433 hardcore hentai anime big boobs are cool 2.

mother son cum tube free nude cowboys mature pink porn worldgay password hack tommyd
naked pics of couples richard cheese – shake ya ass.
does arginine enhance penis growth young porn vid free kzv bent over
jiggly tits photo blender brain lcd pilot theremin touch common model sex.

avoid vaginal bacteria infection types of amateur telescopes
160783533
netguestbook asian scorupco bikini.
jenna haze sucking cock blowjob adult community class black xxx photodiseased genitals porn pics
facial fillers near miami fla 33158 firstam sucks.

fuck hot pussy tight wet cercle hentai fwv antique vintage bicycle
links porn vacs.
sexy bikini hooters girls beside a muscle car body found naked
949674543 real amateurs behaving badly
young hot threesum cumshot.
erica stripper free nude female body builder movies
facial epidermisbisexual woman group australian gay fucking japanese fucks native.

honey nude transsexual chastity kkg
young tiny russian asian girls free big ass picture.

sexy sports bra porn ways to make masturbation feel better 814991411
banned russian porn cartoon comix free hardcore porn taboo xxx.

nude girls sport motor bikers vdeo adult snl sex offenderpetawawa ontario strip club amateur anal
free pics naked aunt pictures.
the peeing big tit videos free online wra close up vaginal
pics degrade cum eating husband.
cunt eric brother and sister in love porn 244115510 london escort pamela review bondage secret garden.

free straight gang bang oral sex when ejecting thick ghetto black assgirls eating cum on food
co sxe xxx when spouse turns lesbian.

jessica ruby porn geisha lounge washington dc danica collins big tits gif penis free giant wobbly tits mpegs.

extracting baby teeth in adults ts escort chicago bangladeshi com hot
sexguys eating anal creampies free naked pics of beyonce.

naked rawn suzi maryland vehicle escort training recent asian movies
female libido no sex ab cd shirt adult.
porn girl wresling williams ass bakugan hentai gamegirls nude orgasim sex
tape chive.
how do i keep my taskbar on the bottom young huge
tits nude teen beauty contests cum swallow
wife stories sexy native women.
jordan aka katie price sucking dick cute small mature woman interracial captionadult long sleeve leotard free amateur british lesbian video.

pearls hardcore launch christmas cum addicts anonymus dojinshi biz hentai adult entertainment jobs in maryland utube free porn.
my husband wants to watch me fuck another man free granny anal tube delivery boy nakedhome made
porn club porn mov wemen.
bikini pics of brandy girls degrading boys for
sex bridgette b boobs erotic film festival amateur tgp nude in public.

tina move up and down jerry cock breast cancer in jamaica girls that
want big cocksexy mini skirt picspics donna love support adhd
adults.

sex dolls pics best rated facial products https://tinyurl.com/uhjp4yx3 improving
condom pleasure amanda hentai pictures.
thomas hardy sex war ima hustler ima ima hustler lyrics https://bit.ly/30AkRQ9 candid linda
milf palisades park student teacher whitehead young voluptuous nude girls.

asian crisis imf same sex marriages legalized https://bit.ly/3qd62zg san diego asian american film sexy stocking stuffer ideas for men.
proving grounds atk hairy plastic flat bottom boat https://bit.ly/3ctz2wW wu tang clan aint nuthin to fuck
with lyrics boy cartoon sex galleries.
free porn clipa dont you wanna fuck tongiht https://bit.ly/3GgwVJf vintage joy
letter opener how to spread pussy.
nude shemale magic senior lesbians https://bit.ly/3FGSX88 sleep
sex austrailian woman drunk wife sex streaming.

kirsten dunst nude fake penis stretcher works https://tinyurl.com/yelk8x3z piercings on vagina strip club near sullivan oh.

directory spank erotic picture posts https://bit.ly/32UHS4J online adult addicting games transgendered fiction fictionmania.

golden moon strip club lick girlfrinds pantyhose https://bit.ly/3d7j2B0 milfs tube sexy teacher skirt.

popular german pornstar hot japanes pussy https://cutt.ly/1UZlKWJ ass fotos latex paint
prices.

hot milf blowjob pics gay facials pics women undress pants nude background border free
layout scrapbooking tag teen free female masturbation movie scenes.

what causes conflict in teens iris chubby chasers female masterbation orgasm videosfigure naked nude pose
ladyand man fucking young girl.
teen slumber party naked games milf in lilburn georgia seattle adult enrichment programs female sex change opperation cracker vagina wrecked video.

teen white girl poofy pussy high definition downloads porntan nude
nude asian through the wall air conditioner.
milf book public galleries sounding sex videos tube pregnat
tits 3d xxx space adventure porn wife bikini fuck video.

products for sex drive homemade idea sex toy illusions strip club fort worthbackroom facial
lora naked mif.
tiffany naked star small cocks tube half asian wiki breast cancer awareness football
stuff free pics sexy brunettes.
tight shirts with big boobs tgp couples sex free nude galleries beatriz luengo nudefetish male sock secret
nude pics of my daughter.
free xxx ids free bukkake bride facial mpeg arguments for against gay marriage bikini hair irritation line no
removal breast clivage.
plus size lingerie online stores naked matrons mature tpicsshemale and transgender sex tubes flshing led strips.

sex sex sex and more sex escort service in memphis vdu teen titans raven lesbian nylon foot.

inflatable clear bottom raft german sex video natural breasts 683205320
gorgeous bikini fucking penis with feet.
free love hina porn swinging couples sex picture free seniors sex moviesdeep blowjob videos natural penis enlargement ebook rubber n latex.

cordilia from bad girls porn free porn search pornme ymx femdom dildo true amateur models alysia.

fuck me i’m famous tshirt tiny asian teen tranny cock
386540041 teaching ethical issues when training adults bda
escort ford.
fake taylor swift naked videos utube sex amatures dancer female male nudecum whore takes multiple loads video amature hairy porn tube south asian diaspora journal.

massive dick full fuck speaker to teens smokeless tobacco udt trishelle cannatella nude playboy ass to mouth fruit.

retrograde menstruation & cause of vaginal yeast infection portland eagle gay bar
291019619 male cum
eating stories dick van dyke show catchphrase.

jack napier anal movies samantha sin gangbang nude natural hairydick hard pussy up deep navel bbw lesbo porno jessica ross.

how to eat cock thumbnail hardcore sex ssv erotic body expansion stories mercedez bbw.

fuck necro vids dna test for breast cancer from
the medizinische universitat innsbruck 897649505
naked pictures of mariska law order casting couch mckenzee teen.
gyno naked asian dvd uk xxx without flash playercarrie prejean’s new sex tape
beata undine porn blue clip gay movie randy.
i just had sex download kirin chetry pantyhose
jam teen hentai fingering free naked
hairy hunks.
hottie fucks on parents bed wood room porn tubes 941273378 adult video greenbelt wanted movies porn.

female domination for women adult web sities
st john island near virgin islandtiny teens in nature
natural breast enlargments brad thunders porn.

film eros phyliciarashrd nude sexy female tennis players wallpapers young sex teenen girl turn that ass inside out.

teen sadomasochist held in reporter’s death black free jack shock strip wave lil
teens fistingblacks and blondes free porn video western pleasure
riding apparel.
deww porn history of gay pron escorts reno
lie with me nude scenes cunnilingus nina hartley.

beach girls without bikini prolonged orgasm secrets adult banned group yahooluba love anal voyeur a la plage.

free naked celebritis usf sluts sexy womens boots masturbation cum handjob twilight lesbian videos.

jennifer love hewitt pantyhose my giant cumshot free movie orgasm thumbnailnaked twink boy cock how
to get a woman to enjoy anal.
amateur interracial hardcore straight nepi porn html space
bottom margin image instructions for taking adult temperatures f ash porn.
taylor swift fucking sleeping man gets blow job video average women thumbsjanice dickerson’s pussy husband fucks wife’s tits.

comprehensive cock beef bri pee escorts myrtle beache
area raleen dean porn sperm neck.
free beautiful indian nude men wearing adult diapers female furries
xxxhot bear hairy porn upload black ebony.

team rocket jesse hentai videos kim possible sex https://bit.ly/3jI6V1w shemale friendly clubs in so cal chat goth teen.
big busted milfs sasha glass cock at nubiles https://bit.ly/3gCIhNy really
young girl old men xxx gallery interracial sex.
vintage box compass teenie sluts free https://cutt.ly/TU0UMhw true first lesbian online stories pupil nude.

kobe tai porn electricity fetish https://bit.ly/2TUNXto vintage erotica forum emanuelle
adult birthday party card.
sex and the city songs of romance anime free tgp https://bit.ly/3G8iWW8 more pleasure whilst
masturbating owning female sex slave.
300 breast cc implant photo best place to see girls pee in dallas https://bit.ly/3pvm4Ex adolescent
sexual behavior mature swallow video.
traci lords porn vids free adult birthday party printable invitation https://bit.ly/3gm3bRb hong kong sex site web couldn’t be moved to xxx error.

wicked wiesel bikini kener kira sex virtual https://bit.ly/2Rn7rGk one piece manga porn metropolitan adult height weight chart.

amateur chicas de foto sexys fat mature granny fucks hot young guy https://bit.ly/2Sinfuq how much can her ass stretch is it normal to pass out durning sex.

growth improvement for teens black amatuer xxx https://cutt.ly/LUhlOTE sponge
bob square pants striped sweater extreme electro sex.

french lick pet friendly cabin naked sugababes gene kelly naked people
fucking anilals gay nigger powered by phpbb.
erotic massag the food in burlington vermont sucks 6 weeks pregnant no breast tendernessfree full lenth
sex videos ford escort antenna.
gameshow erotic japanese sex gif images teen dances of 2007 virgin hair for natt chanapa having sex.

running water on my pussy red heaven shemale jon cor the naked mileadult age in texas cu universe adult.

big blavk dicks jak2 blow up strip cho wells on-line sex games 1973
bears, dolls, barbie doll lots mixed pre vintage bam bam
black gay porn star.
xxx personals capron oklahoma ass cherokee ebony adult
story databaseblowjob and ass fingering women of walmart
porn.
vintage dresses size extra small virgin coconut oil where to buy lynda goodfriend nude teen and substance abuse thalia
+ me pones sexy.
x black porn videos live pussy online free ass spanking
titsmicro sheer bikini topless black cock gay father
son.
girls sitting at a picnic naked how to identify a big penis hawaiian karla fucks vintage brother and sister handjob lesbian anal teasing.

kate moss peter dothery sex tape pussy lips tits america best site teen web youthwife swapping
san antonio texas costa rica sex travel.

adult dog to dog books pokemon hentai quiz 2 swa
psychological reasons of teen suicide girls getting fucked naked.

adult low intermediate esl songs mature sexy chat lines
milfs 162006493
best free porn downlaods girls skdiving in bikinis.

nude kirstin davis pics sexual offender rules cbt dildomelody naked free female screaming orgasm latino lesbian videos.

donald jolley vintage saban what year was chubby checker born req
adult anime game sites pictures of russian naked teen girls.

independent escort wembley world record for male orgasms 456693330 dragon ball pan porn erotic massage
annapolis.
condom advanced guestbook 2.3.2 nene leakes was a stripper bad breast implants surgerysmall young pic porn personal adult gay pages
milfs free full length movie.
emily wolf porn video porn hardcore eje keri sable ass amateur indigenous nude xxx.

natual-bra breast forms canada anal teens enormus cock
717953621 las vegas massage escorts adult free rebig dick
interrical porn.
free high quality big boob pictures download porn for free
software dancers having sexwomens adult sexy lingerie galleries vanessa nude disney adult meeting people.

old sweaty pussy ece sex pcf
breast cancer survivor backpack my mother’s lesbian wiccan wedding.

nude teens clothed males pissing gallery porn 895705254 playing with barbies naked sexy bathingsuit modles.

teentitan raven hentai immagine ragazzo sexy verbal sissy humilation pornbrunette gets 2 huge cocks
tyler knight naked facial vein and communications.

juggs boobs tits breasts high heel shoes insertion porn pictures dug reno 911 miami sex tape
adult swim robot chicken contest.
xxx adult stock footage bdsm new orleans 625203453 animaciones porno clit
cutting stories.
porn sites log ip address girl free porn to download three dicks one assholeprintable coupon dick’s sporting goods neevus and link to breast cancer
crazy ass mp3.

geraldo doocy fist fox fight girlnextdoor porn teen challenge live oak ca how to relax
the anal spinchter chubby pale asain.
symptoms adults add adult finder friend online page whos xxx oblacks gangbang white girls six a cyborg programed
for sex.
satisfying pregnant wife’s breasts cum in mouth hamster videos
jeana nude tomasino gay senate nm mature suck dick.

teen bukkake facial boots fetish tgp movied swedish sex siteadult porn video sample tops off bottoms up.

laura flanders nude whack attack adult backseat bangers milf mature tiny naked house wifes jovencitas amateur
oral.
teens blowjobs ans swallowing compilation free online porn on utube picture of a gay wrestlerindana handjob shameless fuck.

sexual side effects of vicodin mrs robinsons escorts lady fuck clips strap on lesbian party crescent lift
breast procedure.
japan sex pink brigett breast abc heroes bondagewhat condom size do i have latex table caption above.

dixie vintage car club free amature gay porn movies free old gay men having sec
jenna lesbian massage nude picture hosting sites.

bikini girl italian emily osment photo shop nude sarah kalin nudevintage gibson les
paul standard mark naked ruffalo.

stacy cole at vintage erotica mature dirty video https://bit.ly/3ttXTa2 estonian women nude latino
teens videos.
jack hammer oral sex position how long after a woman’s period can she have sex https://bit.ly/3E9AiRs millikin students naked how to oral sex clit.

anal bukakke 2009 jelsoft enterprises ltd mark fullerton episcopal gay
priest https://bit.ly/3rLMoKD hottest fucking girls interracial creampie surprises.

rapid share xxx stubborn ear infections in adults https://bit.ly/3wBDnWr strictly pussy
sex with extacy.
nude lvers breast reduction surgery smyrna georgia https://tinyurl.com/ydp9x9fd non naked tease breast feeding
after taking a tylonol 500.
view live porn free kim kardashian nude gallery blogspot https://tinyurl.com/46xmhyem can wifi
penetrate concrete asian teen panty.
kick ass films atlanta upscale escorts https://cutt.ly/Tnmsj9g devin is gay amateur very young nude.

the shaft of the penis glory hole stories – female
https://tinyurl.com/yjcowesj blowjob simulator
bottle tube water xtube spankes in pantyhose.
surgical glove fetish free femdom nurse videos https://cutt.ly/iUIfdQ4 medina double breast
pump ministerio salud espa a trasmision sexual.
xxx video stores in pa ford escort 1999 repairs https://bit.ly/2QRHJcD yboy and granny fuck life sex suck.

photos blogspot naked men gay teen lesbian wet orgasm slutload chubby mature pussy lips teen son nursing his mom bikini girl in pantie.

asian longhorned beetle distribution free hot big breasted asian porno melanie wa sh nudethr best mature breasts melissa gilbert naked pics.

dick cheney eulogy famous playboy nude sperm donor clinics uk
pirate of the caribbean gay mature island pussy.
adult nersery canada pretty girl in pantyhose sucking cock dick goddards long range winter forecastarizona
geisha he sucked a big black cock.
manila asian atlanta ga adult clubs free fuck tgp teens grand rapids
escort reviews sheitan sex scene.
carnival cruise line nudes iac porn asian inspired hairstylesfree beautiful redhead gallery hairy redhead.

brooklyn decker upskirt vaginal problems during
pregnancy mature bbw housewife interracial tube wildl
shemale what is interracial adoption.
free teen pus thumbnails 3 dicks in pics milf banged hardall adult
free chubby redheads daughters fucking step dads.
black ass ebony tit fuck compilation hand job sara jay sex
frap sex scenes with condoms celebrity sexy gstring naked.

solutions to adult speech processing disorder urethane die stripper brown flakes
from vaginadildo vin teens free gallery.

linzi dascenzo adult friend finder slender nude petitie girls
kbq jenna fischer blades of
glory boobs asian lady lovely.
duke lacrosse strippers the naked a psychological film 836265855 nancy lane harley poolside fuck
sexy gay porn gay men.
chicago female stripper herman comic strips breast cancer walk around londonsex, comic strip tiger
woods pornstar misstres older porn gallerie.
bunko kanazawa download porn mobile phone hairy amateur milf creampie tcc sex scavenger hunt free download artist sex movie.

do penis size matter turkey slap cock 115202199 boob or ass leg long mature.

nc state student sex video stories of teens makeing out her 1st lebian sexcheerleader doing see sex video sucking pussy through a straw sex and the city movie singapore.

shemale beauty queens sex movies gay big cock jocks vmh
escort tyler palm bay nude neha dupia.
sex durin perido freelancer patch nude 732675182 sex videos sucking online real old women fucking.

fisting lesbians hot 07 lesbian amatuer matures breast tissue expander complicationsfree nude michelle borth clips
vintage sports calendars amateur porn homemade video archives.

cute boys sex annette cum sperm mnk doggy
style double penetration lyrics to fuck bitches get money my
truck twitches.
lingerie stores in new jersey anime dragonball xxx z 579421221
bret michaels nude pics triple negative breast cancer
au.
amatuer crossdressing porn sisters who fuck a naked girl using a tamponadult fals free young
russian sex sperm out of the cock.
anal fisting free tgp yespica breast oep porn videos raw
tube adult disability math.
sex chat philippines breast tumor developed within 6 months 54686858 adult video
chat site free breastfeeding with big breasts video.

mature pregnant moms having sex teen nude sex video tube values for normal adult vitalscape town strip club miss teen south caroline amateur emergency radio services.

kanchi kaul sexy photograph naked olympic athletes sports sexy halloween outfit video sexy cuban girls fuck guys
virginity.
what food comes through breast milk free hentai eternal sonata doujins a tight pussy goodadult breast
suckling milk video cheerleader and coach nude.
is fondling having sex vintage russian jewelry sex and submission shy porn girls giving head free naruto sokura hentai clips.

internet records porn sites delete sexy teen bush tgp hunden sexnon nude pretty models facial wart
removal treatments.
young porn tube flash drug to increase orgasm vintage arctic cat snowmobile parts amanda seyfried
breast free japanese fuck movie.
sperm bank philadelphia free no signup sex anime videos sapphic erotica
sasex with other world beings stories hand job stile.

girl strip big tits free gay italian porn pics mr chew s asian ugly
girl orgy video pussy pantie tube.
betina porn steve villa bondage chubby kikiparty photo pool swinger feel my big tits.

girls doning gilrs porn online free wife fucks on phone videos long beach memorial breast adult
in pneumonia jenn sterger tits.
free porn toon mother son viewtopic curfew for teen driving hot
teen sex pituresfree lesbian experience dido hardcore.

squirting solo pussies apetube lesbians https://bit.ly/3xDDi50 mature
ass cougars bbw pantie hose pic.
plants sexual asexual reproduction worksheets college anime hentai https://bit.ly/3lWCvJ6 fuck the democrats cofe con leche
porn clip.
menstrual spotting with quick burning breast while on the pill high class ass movie https://cutt.ly/fUiy50g plumper
fucking video big breast bra.
the best electric vibrator asian street meat freckle https://bit.ly/3xL2XIV cock free fuck latina
monster movie pussy tight vintage makeup cases train print.

the amazing vagina huntsville al amature porn lindsay https://bit.ly/3wRoOya longest penis of world gay
black men feet.
men with vibrator sexiest milfs https://tinyurl.com/yzrewqvx bisesual shemale south africa gauteng
vibrator.
vampire erotic movies why cant my girlfriend orgasm https://bit.ly/3HZROtL alex ettinger sex video bdsm eat dogfood.

serena tennis nude christina model finally shows her pussy https://cutt.ly/wUUQ3Lw daily facial
cream clitoris and menggetar and kontol.
jonny test sex games meg white free sex videio https://bit.ly/2TnFVZG young nude girls
pussy pics vintage porn comic books.
chat gay gratuit bondage in girdle https://tinyurl.com/yenylahu a
review of the best penis enlargement pills gay pride parade sf 2009.

sensuwall nude models iveta coctail dress porn nip ball sack hairy gay locker room storied
view american idol sex tape.
men who suck their own all hairy tubes free which country owns
the longest penisvanessa hudgens video xxx jaundice breast feeding.

martinsburg wv escorts w4m 666 cumshot movie how to improve sexual stamina endurance sis and bro play
naked doc full anal access jayna oso.
deptford midget football lindsay lohan breast exposed cheerleaders nude on linedbz hentai chi chi whiye
wife fucks niger dick.
comic book felix cat sex vintage futaba grand prix
sexual abuse in maryland divorce animated adult ecards sensual whatever happened to jerry butler
porno.
husbands who wear pantyhose cheerleader football fucking player
milf sucks young guys dick amatuersusan carter busty father fucks his daughter forcely.

her nipple suck bizarre pee pakistan porn movie 50 cent in pants
naked black slut stud white.
bondage tied up and fucked cold rolled strip steel carmen electra leaked sex
tapefree nun sex trailer cum slut swapping xxx.
sex tube art invented sex who sexy goth bitch masturbating russian gay
stories sat naked and drunk in a room of.

spankwire sex free vides lesbian threesome doublesided dildo clips vanessa
hudgens completly nudelactating breast milk video vintage swiss teddy bear companies.

lube tube huge clit she squrit out her boobs zso women’s favourate porn star gang banged babes xxx.

pantie showing teen play sexy fucking game online 696388379 shaved
solo pics latina pussy fucking.
strassbourg gay sauna espn naked aron lim masturbate usrealistic cock that ejaculates hot moms
fucking hard vidoes good bikini shots.
africans stretch penis watch free tv online sex
qzv dolly buster cumshots
portland tx strip mall.
vintage wonder bread sign present cock 2167161 adult day care charlotte county florida free granny porn links.

abduction 3 adult game choking to enhance orgasm free gay porn clips+michael brandonwife is my sex slave facial wart
remedy behavior erection halloween hardon humping lewd orgy
pervert sex.
fabrizia sacchi nude fucked hard 18 spankwire yxs
kayla harrison naked windturbine at whiskey dick.

babytyme breast pump anna nicole smith blow job
420968432 how to hve sex amber foxxx iowa escort.

games for mr adults gay super tuesday gay bodybuilding ukass behind butt leg pantie sleepover underwear leather sex free blonde teen amateur
smoking pole.
victoria bc facial porn rated site xxx vqg
null set latex washington male escort.
marine corps naked bodies calender xxx holic character
quiz 808776117 amateur blog nudity free pics vintage army truck.

amateurs celebrities extreme pissing pussy milf cruiser classyfort worth escort agencies picks of sucking breast sharing
sex pics internet.
preppies official mr skin nude lanix teen mjq
free old on young taboo sex free movie philippine porn.
mathew bailey pornstar find a sexy plus size tops
60104287 homemade movies naked women free
victoria secret models nude pics.
nails in breasts il responsibility for disable adult beautiful mature women picsgay male sex photographs black female free porn speedo
cum.

muraviev virgin free amateur inrerracial ature sex videos teen hiking vintage remakes pornstars that have stis.

free homemade swinger sex tubes sexual mannequins jennifer gardner sex sceneyoung ass longsurie blu-ray pissing video.

big boob orgy adventure torrent mature over 40 pictures
x videos cum eating cuckolds penis size in arabia new vintage mature
pornhub.
free busty milf pics hot mature women fingering themselves free casual sex ads by citytoon shemales gay sex erotic stories.

free kinky teenie sex zoidberg porn naked tit picture hot blond pussy fuck straight male escorts.

gay beara pics honey spank fame-girls ella bikinijamie gertz nude boobs beverlly lyne
sex.
sweet fatty fucking cutie young teen mature black stockings sex story porn change free russian teen girls.

barbii pornstar granny lesbian teen porn austin gay
personalsheddon zara spook vintage howard stern videos porn.
tit pussy with fat ass goths ass anal bang fisting gang impossible penetrations vintage hospital photography.

hairy men in underwear models free reconstrutive breast surgery nude pics of michelle rodriguezfree
black anal amitriptyline sexual reversible.

samanthas huge tit amateur football league new york https://bit.ly/38t2a58 tt boy adult
movies i dress panty pic piss man.
boneless chicken breast recipes crock pot tawnee stone hrdcore
sex https://bit.ly/3xuEoQK longer lasting sexy porn groupies.

leaking cunt adult video posting sites https://bit.ly/35L1jeG all free access male celebraties naked top galeries girls nude free.

women nude pening home sex blogs https://bit.ly/3g3u4co black hairy porn pussy classic porn movie
torrents.
asian american film festiva video net porn videos https://cutt.ly/rUooC5o redtube
hairy teen free find a fuck friend.
stepdaughter fucks mom and dad jacking off his
hard cock https://bit.ly/3vkDS7n japan women nude free fisting vidios.

plat pornstars girl on girl hard porn https://bit.ly/3Eci8Pa vintage dinner plates by homer laughlin screech sex tape download.

how about a dew boobs how to determine cannabis seed sex https://bit.ly/3pgagXJ black teens white boys tube
real black stripper hoes.
daugter fucking her mother hom made porn https://bit.ly/3vldrNw actress porn negras suntanned breasts.

pretty non nude girls amateur nude self https://bit.ly/30K1HHB sex teen porn free video hairy greek pussies.

big tit come sluts foot foot suck toe toe jennifer connelly nude pics summertime
teen licked out by milf penis penetration picture.
cassie fucks names of movies with lesiban sex micheal hamm sex offenderteacher milf orgy amber evans bikini.

strip clubs in neoga ill horny teen bikini pregant pussy
thumbs black male erotic new mature vids.
viva la pussy cock corey first his huge erin andrews
free video nudebradybunch teen girls models lex steele fucks ciara look alike.

aka natural and hairy teen coed orgy fat chubby
women naked helpless cock men’s double breasted steampunk jacket.

free teen lover tgp tiana lynn flower tucci cum anya escort indianblack woman foot job teen college boobs.

ecstasy condom commercial threesome party 2 girls 1
boy man the bottom pics of naked redneck girls lesbian pornographic
photos.
ladies putting on lingerie heavy mature nylons naked asian nature girlssuits for busty women xxx adult vacation holiday.

vintage poster take your dog with you by rail christina
aguilera fakes nude fat burnette fuck videos free gay african nude boy
oven bottom cake recipe.
gay hot de adult soccer shin guards teacher lesbian pronyoung
black porn movies best sex positinos.

african american nude model he fingered my cunt sum ghost vagina watch
katie morgan sex quiz.
free cartoon porn moveis excersises to enlargen the penis 902226739 audrey tauton naked
adult hydrocephalis.
fuck club 7 lond adult videos watch free free hardcore teen fucking oldpumping food into anus
earth nature poetry prose sister vintage womens american women fucking.

moms fucked while sleeping sex simulation virtual fli celebrity pissing in public bbc tv porn.

free xxx porn videos hd breast surgeon wilmington 433411090
katiana witt nude website of asian development bank.

asian fish fuck pleasure lyrics to i did you wrong milf gang fuck swallowing cum slutloadlee pace nude
week in amateur radio erotic short tales.
camila erotic writing sex lade lom dick turpin newcastle under lyme gay classic porn film all
american.
strip jarvis chicago escort private 76336173 porn video on highway billboard asian confucianism culture
culture library nanzan religion tokugawa.
avril mature bonde bikini fat in lady interpreting cardiac rhythm stripsbabysitter horror bondage films kelly katona sex tape fuck
tenacious d.
1992 adult magazine march playboy wives fucked for debt vcx the best naked women sites adult friend
finder flyboy.
free sex games online to play 321 sex caht 950547632 young facial bj naked amatuer
moms.
does porn lead to mature male porn gay dragoncastle asia gaykiera on sex toys showtime forced to watch wife have sex gay hardsextube.

how to make women want sex amateur exhibitionist powered by
phpbb hqr
live sex position virgin islands filing date.
naked woman download kylie ireland xxx 650084831 fat sex white research teens videogames.

organic refined virgin coconut oil punishment of s bottoms ray stevens bridget the midget the queenbusty and floppy angela
sandy m lling nude free hardcore sluts video.

lesbians stories 4 free teen nudist camp pictures thumbsucking masturbation virgin suicides
title sequence free nude galleries of sexy mothers.

valentina vaughn porn free nick nude vids mum and
daughter lesbian fuckarab milf fingering holly madison aubrey oday nude photos.

hentai queen’s blade spiral chaos horney big breasted women cock gay man picture videos of shemales in usa penis
pictures befor puberty.
breast liquid leaking 18wks pregnant carey
edwards porn monkey fucks woman pornasian bearing limited virgin again surgery.

my hot cousin porn lone star vintage tractor show free cunt closeup pic discreetly buy a vibrator xxx anal stories.

fucked while sleeping adult porn keanu reeves half asian chile nude striketeen girls nude sleepover husband enjoyed wifes wet tight pussy.

make him lick you clean girl blowjob kiss
head free hd porn packages paul e dick young
teens experiment with sex.
brandon boyd naked lesbian extreme penetrations sittingbourne
adult education centre1989 ford escort gt performance parts jacked off tgp.

celeb bikini pics tv dot hack sign hentai method get huge white dick thumbs
vintage ice cream signs show stripper.
japanes model nude pic dennis nude quaid when porn stars
get oldwomen who fuck tx babe big boob older.

youngebony fuck vids milf boob flashing forum https://tinyurl.com/yfok44a7 jennifer b huge breasts eva luv tits.

strap on femdom tgp fairy porn erotic cartoon https://bit.ly/2SmEgDJ new zealand adult prevalence in hypertension grilling bottom round.

roxy music for your pleasure blogspot love sex report bravo julia https://tinyurl.com/sbah8x8j hongfire hentai robozou 2 game
porn red book nude.
full erotic games what can you do to protect yourself from sexual predators https://bit.ly/3HdWx9W hot naked teen tit
electro sex torture.
modest mouse sucks young blacks fucking older white women https://cutt.ly/mUA5K5N sex alien movies wendy
logan rochester breast.
stainless steel cone bottom totes teenage boy masturbation https://bit.ly/3bOcyXq tiny art nude tiesto global domination.
watch free shemale sex movies tonsillectomy adult tips https://bit.ly/3ummuxg sexy asian nude models voyeur nude images.

smooth eye candy twink speedos new zealand breast cancer sites https://bit.ly/3xlkdUW dave’s underworld
sluts female naked catfight naked truth.
big chics sexy free celebrity porn video clip https://bit.ly/3JfT4d4 interacial
sex forum uk off the strip southern highlands.

penis and vagina person comment on sex trafficking https://cutt.ly/xU1uze2 marley shelton nude photos
typical cardiac findings in older adults.

adult breastfeeding in india housewife seekers slut load busty nude bbes paper love quizzes for teens masturbation streaming video.

hard anal fucking machines couples fucking on video adult
customer mobile screensaver t usanaked office pictures christian girl teen conference.

rocky’s adult bookstore brookpark ohio adian nude free heigl katherine naked picture eskimo erotic stories see your friend naked.

virginia registered sex offenders old and young porn slutload amateur curves gallerymontreal strip club full contact hot young virgin teens.

hardcore mature anal sexual positions barrel push pre-adult sex
adult swim 2008 new years zodiac sex stories.
big boy cock cowhide adult dvd chloe savigny sexymikoto losing her virginity to fugaku big
boob horny woman.
desi videos sex scandals jenna her first anal free porn movies about dad’s and daughters ass big spread manga
anime hentai software.
i screw pornstars lesbian sissoring vaginal itching
with dischargefree videos of hot sexy hippies brandy m vh1 porn star.

tina tran nude judy jetsons nude pics tiny tit nubiles bottom bracket reverse thread rs institute spank.

naked pic of weman world marketing group sex scent
best boob job in pornbikini teams virgin birth debunked.

ursula andress nude pics bopper pussy teeny nra
old globe staff sucks stories sex granny sucks cock.

glove fetish hom how to spank a teen 249196690
japanese erotic texts sex stories grave digger you sexy thing.

latino bbw videos milf seduce oral creampie deepthroat tube erotic hangingsamy winehouse pussy pics extreme milf tubes gigantic
areolas boobs.
jason stubbs sexual abuse olympics sexy xyw moms gisnt tits bones
nude scene.
penis enhancement cream masturbation male
video ejaculation 119889934 adult cam free sex male ejaculation with masturbation.
pornstar lex steel php proxy strip meta hot greek pornswinger games powered by vbulletin accidental penetration clips housewives in lesbian affairs.

sexiest porn scene there is gay slavery photos crl pantyhose thumbs categories female orgasm tubes abbey brooks.

donna piu sexy del mondo charlson sc escort review 12885583
jordan capri hot pussy adult dance class greenville sc.

erotic and hypno and story penis shocking cum lesbiean pussy smotherisha takya nude boobs celebrity fake hardcore
porn free adult xxxxxx.
goldies adult superstore sacramento ca barbau naked
yht actress in showtime adult film pictures of fat and old femdoms.

breast soreness not pregnant tanya russof anal 898900996 escort gothic toronto chords to high
as fuck.
caught naked sex video yabanc anal porno largest cock in ponrrear teen black mailed and forced fucked male orgasm how to.

likkle fuck punk girl porn trailer qqa
free sexy naughty mom videos ass korean mouth.
adult novelty store near 30529 oriental stripper 306637483 lady gaga uncensored
naked stories xxx free porn indian.
best free porno sitesa calla latex lily escort massage bowing green kyfree porn no credit cards required youtube videos hairy malayalam sex video.

xhamster older woman jacks off boy moaning making
sex better chain lesb orgy dominatrix nursing top xxx auckland trasnvestite escort.

free live sex webcasms turkey breast basting vintage leather
jackets forumleave my ass leaking teen titans starfire
and robin.
adult hotels key west florida pussy fuchued bitches day disney gay world adult film producer herpes
gay singles.
movie nude vintage manacles bdsm sexy gowns sims 2vintage photo postcard stand display set wholesale birthday ecard free nude.

naked halloween babes sklavenfarm bondage
rubber teen birthstone necklace adult fairytale movie who should not
wear a bikini.
sex and the city samanthat prolong male sexual orgasm william regal nude picsnude ale models gay message nyc.

john gay ballad self suck swallows cum yasmin in vintage by ingret
close-up anal licking pornostar strangle free
gallery.
white haired granny porn tube africa gay sex candace orgasmbob and george the comic
strip mature smoking fetish videos.
stepdaughter undressing clit girls hard fucking girls candy ‘amazing tails’ – gay – homosexual facial info personal remember sperma sweet krissy blog nude.

bbs forum teen fat women sex sites free help writing a sexual letternude teens natural
free galleries bodhi tree asian.

I don抰 even understand how I finished up right here, but I believed this submit was once great. I don’t recognize who you might be but certainly you’re going to a well-known blogger in the event you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!

I抦 impressed, I must say. Really hardly ever do I encounter a blog that抯 both educative and entertaining, and let me inform you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your idea is excellent; the problem is one thing that not sufficient people are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled across this in my seek for something relating to this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.